Nothing contradicts with quran, quran infact is talking about Idhaah in reference to pre-mature girls.Garudaman wrote:no, I assume that because its contradict with the Quran!manfred wrote:Hi garudaman,
OK, as far as it goes, an honest answer, so I congratulate you on that. But there is a problem: You assume that because something is quite horrible it did not happen.
sahih is just mean that the witness is honest, but honest isn't same with true!manfred wrote:We have multiple independent reports to that effect, telling us the age as well as the circumstances of this "marriage".... all wrong? Why did the scholars call them sahih? Were they wrong too?
not in accordance with the Quran is the Muslims?manfred wrote:And at the end of the day what matters most to me is not so much what happened so long ago, let the dead judge the dead, but what Muslims BELIEVE that happened and how it rules their lives today, that is very important because it impacts on many lives.
We have a great many similar "marriages" by Muslims today, mostly in Arab countries, but also in Pakistan. So clearly Muslims generally believe this story and take it as an example.
of course!manfred wrote:I think just when it comes to chat to guys like us you get a little embarrassed, lost for words and you wish this topic would simply go away. So let me ask you, would you say the same thing to your Muslim friends?
I wouldn't use the sources that can't be verified unless we can get back to the past, but if you curious : http://www.muslim.org/islam/aisha-age.htm" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;manfred wrote:OK... do you have any historical sources supporting that?Spoiler! :
All the Islamic scholars agree that he married to 9 years old Aisha , so you saying it did not happened means nothing. If you say sahi hadith is actually not true, in a muslim country they will kill you on the spot for blasphemy. So you are alone here while rest of the muslim world believes he married when Aisha was sex and had sex with her when she was 9. Which is true because of so many sahi hadiths , they can not be all wrong. They have no reason to lie. So no matter how hard you try you can not get out of it.